Buying guide

How to choose an influencer marketing agency

A practical shortlisting method for influencer agencies — what evidence to ask for, how to weigh it, and the warning signs to look for.

By Influencer Agency Index research desk · Published · Updated · 2 min read

Most agency websites say the same things: creative, data-driven, award-winning, global. The way to tell them apart is to ask for evidence and check it. This is the method we use for the index, adapted for a buyer running a shortlist.

Step 1: Write the brief before you look

Decide four things first, because they remove most agencies from the list before you start:

  • Markets. Which countries must have a team on the ground, not just “coverage”?
  • Platforms. Where is most of the budget going — TikTok, Instagram, YouTube, or somewhere else?
  • Services. Creators only, or creators plus paid social, community management, production or commerce?
  • Commercial model. Project, retainer, or performance-linked fees?

Step 2: Check published proof of work

Look for case studies that name the client, the platform and at least one measured result. Logo walls do not count; anyone can display a logo. Ask for two case studies in your category and one in your main market.

Step 3: Check who owns the agency

Since 2023, WPP, Publicis, Accenture and PMG have each bought influencer agencies in this index. Ownership affects how fast decisions get made, which media agency you will be steered toward, and whether your agency can work with competitors’ holding companies. Neither independent nor holding-company is better by default — but you should know which you are buying. Read independent vs holding-company agencies.

Step 4: Ask how they measure

Ask what they report as the primary success metric. Reach and earned media value (EMV) are easy to inflate. Sales, tracked conversions, brand-lift or cost per outcome are harder to fake. See how to measure influencer ROI.

Step 5: Meet the actual team

The pitch team is not always the delivery team. Ask who will run the account day to day, where they are based and how many other accounts they handle.

Warning signs

  • Case studies without a client name or a date.
  • Only EMV or impressions as results.
  • Unclear answers about who owns the agency.
  • Reluctance to separate agency fees from creator fees.
  • Partner badges that do not appear on the platform’s own directory or the agency’s site.

Use our RFP question list to put these checks into a formal process.

Agencies mentioned

Related guides